# Question: 2nd Ball is Yellow

## Comment on 2nd Ball is Yellow

### Can we solve this problem

Can we solve this problem using the complement rule?

### Sure, give it a try.

Sure, give it a try.

### Hi,

Hi,
I tried using complement rule, but I got 2/25 instead of 1/25, can you analyze where I went wrong?

P( having second ball yellow)= 1-P( 2nd not being yellow)
= 1-P( 2nd being either red+ 2nd being green)
= 1-(12/25 x 12/24+ 12/25 x 11/24+ 12/25 x 12/24 +12/25 x11/24)
= 1-( 12/25 + 11/25)
= 1-23/25
= 2/25 (what went wrong?)

### It's hard to tell, because

It's hard to tell, because you haven't really explained all of your steps. However, I believe you forgot to include P(1st ball is yellow and 2nd ball is ANY color)

This probability = (1/25)(24/24) = 1/25
I think this is your missing 1/25

### I have a doubt here. The

I have a doubt here. The question asks for the probability that the second ball is yellow. Considering that the 1st ball selected is a non yellow ball, in the formula-> P(A AND B) = P(A) * P(B|A). Here isn't it true that we have to only find the probability of the last part of formula which is P(B|A)? So considering that the 1st ball selected is non yellow, then we have 24 balls remaining among which 1 is yellow, so the answer is 1/24? why is this not correct? Please explain.

### In order for the 2nd ball to

In order for the 2nd ball to be yellow, the 1st ball must be NON-YELLOW. So, we have to factor that into our equation.

That is, P(2nd ball yellow) = P(1st ball is not yellow AND 2nd ball is yellow)

We can't just assume that the first ball is not yellow, since there's a 1/25 chance that the first ball is yellow.

Cheers,
Brent

### I don't get it... it says the

I don't get it... it says the second ball has to be yellow... my interpretation is that the first ball can be ANY colour...?
SO:
P(any ball AND yellow ball) = 25/25 x 1/24 = 1/24

Why do we have to say that the first ball is NOT yellow...?
WAIT! I think I figured out the answer while typing this... this is true because we have only 1 yellow ball!

TRICKY question! Read the question carefully ya'll.

### Good catch, KB23! :-)

Good catch, KB23! :-)